New York's 'Click to Cancel' rule targets subscription traps

The brief in 6 cards

1. Note1 / 6

   WHY IN NEWS?

   • New York City's "Click to Cancel" rule took effect on 1 October 2026.
   • It was finalised in July under Mayor Zohran Mamdani and is enforced by the city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection.
   • It applies to automatic renewals and continuous service offers.
   • New York is the first US city with such a rule; several US States have similar laws.
   • The Roosevelt Institute estimates savings for New Yorkers of $21.5 million to $162.5 million a year.
2. Note2 / 6

   WHAT THE RULE REQUIRES

   • Same method: If you signed up online, you must be able to cancel online.
   • Simple process: No forced phone calls or confusing chains of pages.
   • Clear terms: Renewal dates, charges and cancellation steps must be disclosed.
   • Penalties: Fines start at $525 per violation, with restitution for consumers.
   • Complaints: Residents can report violations through a city portal.
3. Note3 / 6

   KEY CONCEPTS

   1. What are dark patterns?

   They are website or app designs that trick users into choices they did not intend, such as hidden charges or hard-to-find cancel buttons.

   2. What is a subscription trap?

   It makes signing up easy but cancelling hard, so people keep paying for services they no longer want.

   3. What is the CCPA?

   The Central Consumer Protection Authority was set up under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. It acts against unfair trade practices, misleading ads and violations of consumer rights.

   4. What are India's dark-pattern guidelines?

   Issued by the CCPA in November 2023, they list 13 banned dark patterns, including subscription traps, false urgency, basket sneaking and confirm-shaming.

4. Note4 / 6

   INDIA'S GAPS

   • Split rules: Consumer law sits with the CCPA, while recurring payments fall under RBI rules.
   • Payment alerts help, but are not enough: RBI requires banks to notify customers at least 24 hours before an auto-debit. This does not make cancelling with the merchant easy.
   • Low awareness: Many users do not notice auto-renewal terms.
   • Weak redress: Complaint processes can be slow and confusing.
   • Loopholes: Repeated "are you sure?" screens can still obstruct cancellation.
5. Note5 / 6

   WAY FORWARD

   These are suggested measures, not approved policy.

   • Adopt a same-medium rule: Cancelling should be no harder than signing up.
   • Mandate clear disclosure of trial expiry, renewal charges and billing cycles.
   • Audit platforms and impose proportionate penalties.
   • Coordinate the CCPA and RBI on recurring payments.
   • Educate consumers on auto-renewals and how to revoke mandates.
6. Note6 / 6

   

Swipe or use ← → to move between cards.